|
YORK COUNTY – York County Sheriff Paul Vrbka recently had a very interesting visit – a visit with a man who had been researching the death of another York County Sheriff, which happened 110 years ago. And the man has been seeking to have the former sheriff formally honored because he died in the line of duty. “Dave Swavely stopped by to see me, on his way to New York,” Sheriff Vrbka explained. “He is a retired lieutenant with the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Department in Colorado. He did a lot of research into the death of York County Sheriff John Henry Afflerbach. I was able to verify some of his information in an old jail register book I found in the basement of the courthouse. In the old book, I found Afflerbach’s name mentioned as he made arrests. And I found the name of the man accused of killing him, as he had been arrested for horse theft here in York County.”
Swavely’s research paper, which he gave to Sheriff Vrbka, says “Sheriff Afflerbach was killed in the line of duty in April of 1916 but he has never received the honor of a line of duty death determination nor a memorial place for his remembrance. Now, over 100 years after his death, this research paper will establish a case for his name to be placed on the National Law Enforcement Officer’s Memorial.” Afflerbach was a law enforcement officer, starting in at least 1891 in the City of York and York County, Nebraska, Swavely says. “He served as elected sheriff of York County from 1910-1914. By 1915, he had retired and moved to a homestead in Montana. In the spring of 1916, Afflerbach was notified by the (sitting) York County Sheriff that a young man named Harry Randolph had stolen a car in York and was heading to Montana. Afflerbach knew Randolph and had arrested him at least twice in York, Nebraska, when Randolph was a young man. Afflerbach did locate Randolph in Montana and took him into custody.” But they never arrived in Nebraska as intended. Swavely provided to Sheriff Vrbka a copy of an old newspaper article in which a variety of rewards were offered from York organizations and entities in an effort to find information about the disappearance of Afflerbach and Randolph. “Members of the Knights of Pythias Lodge at York, Neb., of which John Afflerbach, the former York sheriff and Montana rancher, who mysteriously disappeared while escorting a prisoner back to York from Grass Range, was a member, is making strenuous efforts to find some trace of the missing man and his prisoner Harry Randolph, wanted in York for stealing an auto. Randolph, it is alleged, stole a Buick car from York and was arrested by Afflerbach, who had been made a special constable for that purpose after the car had been traced to Randolph’s homestead near Grass Range. Together they left Grass Range and on April 14 arrived at the N-Bar ranch. On April 17, Randolph was seen at Gothenburg, Neb., and on the following day in Harrisburg, alone and without the automobile which, it is believed, he left in Billings. Afflerbach has never been seen since. The car was painted green with bronze stripes, black hood and fender and green wheels. York County offers a reward of $100 and citizens of York offer $100 for the arrest and delivery of Randolph; an insurance agency offers $100 for the location of the car and the Knights of Pythias Lodge of York offers $100 for information leading to the whereabouts of Afflerbach, dead or alive.” Swavely’s information explains how “in August of 1916, Randolph was found with the stolen car and arrested in Boulder, Colorado, and sent back to Nebraska. He claimed to have no knowledge of the whereabouts or fate of Afflerbach. He was extradited back to Montana to face murder charges. Those charges were dropped, however, for without a victim, witness or confession, a successful prosecution was not likely. Randolph was returned to York and he went to prison on the burglary/auto theft charges. In 1922, Randolph was arrested in New Orleans, Louisiana, and during an escape attempt, shot and killed a police officer and was then killed. He never confessed to the murder of Afflerbach. “Over the years, the investigation into Afflerbach’s disappearance continued as discoveries of human remains were checked in various locations in Montana and Nebraska, but none were validated as being Afflerbach. It will be clear, however, that Afflerbach was killed in the line of duty. Further, he is not currently listed on any known memorial but is deserving of this honor, even more than 100 years after his ultimate sacrifice.” “This was a fascinating meeting I had with Mr. Swavely and I think his efforts to have Sheriff Afflerbach honored is a great thing,” Sheriff Vrbka said. “Meanwhile, I think I’m going to have a small memorial plaque made with Afflerbach’s photo on it and have it mounted in the lobby of the sheriff’s office. I just thought this story was extremely interesting and really, a part of York County history.” Editor’s note: We have since received the following information from JR Wolfe, a former York resident who is retired law enforcement. He has informed us, “There is a later newspaper item, Afflerbach showed up alive later. After he went after Harry Randolph it appears Afflerbach went back home to Pennsylvania. He did not die in the line of duty. “Capt. Afflerbach died 20 May 1920 in Haycock, Bucks County, Pennsylvania, at age 79. He is buried in Kellers Church Union Cemetery, Perkasie, Pennsylvania. To see his gravestone, go to https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/56404600/john-henry-afflerbach.” This information will be passed on to the man who has been researching this matter for many years. Comments are closed.
|
Archives
November 2026
Categories
All
|
YORK COUNTY, NEBRASKA